
On stage at Tim Murphy's reelection launch last night, the name Evan Feinberg was never uttered. A number of the tried-and-true Murphy supporters I talked to in the crowd didn't know who he was, and if they did know, he was often referred to only as "The Kid."
"How old is the kid?" asked former congresswoman Melissa Hart, as she sat at a ballroom table in the Doubletree in Green Tree, preparing her introduction of Murphy, a five-term incumbent and friend since their days in the state Senate. No one, including Murphy's longtime political advisor Mike DeVanney, knew his age for sure, other than it was something in the 20s. (He's 27.)
Hart would not mention Feinberg or his age in her remarks later but she didn't have to. "In a year where everything is disrupted -- even in our own party, as you see in the presidential race, and now Tim having a primary -- it's important to really examine what he's done. . . He's been strong and he's been a conservative voice," she said.
Murphy, the PA18 Republican from Upper St. Clair, voted against Obamacare, against cap-and-trade, Dodd-Frank and other Democratic initiatives. (A fact sheet distributed at the rally was called "The Murphy Record: Representing Southwestern Pennsylvania's Conservative Values in Congress.") But that's not good enough for many on the far-right side of the party, which is where Feinberg comes in. The
former Senate staffer to Tea Party favorites Rand Paul and Tom Coburn came back to town (he grew up in Peters and went to Grove City) last year to try to topple Murphy, who some see as too close to labor unions and too moderate for today's GOP.
Feinberg has been aided by harsh criticisms of Murphy by influential voices at
Red State and the
Club For Growth, and today the conservative editorial page of the Tribune-Review turned up the intraparty heat to 11,
calling Murphy a "weasel" for backing away from his 2007 card-check vote this campaign season.
Murphy took the stage and started out by attacking Obama and listing his votes against health care reform and other presidential agenda items, and repeating conservative criticisms of a failed Obama administration undercover gun operation in Mexico and the solar energy company Solyndra. He repeated oft-heard stories his past as a doctor (he used to appear on KDKA-TV as medical expert "Dr. Tim"), and it appeared he would take the usual frontrunner's path of staying above the fray and keeping his comments, Romney-like, on Obama rather his primary opponent.
It used to be that Murphy's resume and moderate record were lauded, for allowing him to survive as a Republican in a traditionally labor and Democratic-friendly area. Not anymore, apparently, and so Murphy pivoted from his personal history and bills he's sponsored to oblique comments that were nonetheless clearly about The Kid. "Those are things that I've learned from you and [are why] I represent you," he told the roughly 100 people in the ballroom. "I didn't have to make a decision to say I think I'll move to Pittsburgh so that I can run for office and do something."
He spoke about his medical past, his family and his many runs for state Senate and Congress, then said "there are other unanticipated moments in our lives that teach us incredible lessons, and I'm telling you folks, we're going to need those lessons to take us through what we're facing the next couple years. And it's going to take tremendous courage."
The former child psychologist went on. "There's a lot of people in this country who are frustrated. We're all frustrated. Some are very angry. What we cannot do is take out that anger out on ourselves. Those of us who believe in this country, want to work for this country and protect our Constitution and keep taxes low . . . we're going to have to work together and not be divisive."
Murphy has many advantages in this race. A chemical lobby has
already run ads on his behalf, and he should show a fundraising advantage on Feinberg when the latest FEC reports are filed by Tuesday. Still, many eyes (including those of
Democrat Larry Maggi, who would be thrilled at a Feinberg win) will be glued to this most unanticipated moment.