Print

Today in Voter ID; Trial ends, Slate covers

Published by Tim McNulty on .

Closing arguments are due this morning in the legal challenge of the state's Voter ID law. The ACLU's Vic Walczak previews his argument that the state should suspend the law -- partially there was no evidence presented of election day fraud, and therefore the state would not be harmed by an injunction -- above.

Karen Langley gets into more of those arguments in her story on the last day of evidence in the Commonwealth Court trial. In Philly, they're expecting "a mess on election day," a city official testified.

And if you haven't already check out the stuff Dave Weigel at Slate has been doing on the trial. Sample on the testimony of that official, Jorge Santana:

"Wouldn't you agree with me," asked state attorney Kevin Schmidt, "that this is really just speculative, about what will happen on election day. Is that correct?"

"No," said Santana. "It's not correct. We have a basis of experience from our elections, and we have evidence of concern from judges of elections and participants in elections currently, questions that are being raised now."

Schmidt's question had backfired, so he asked it again. "So... you're saying that this is a new experience," he started.

"No," said Santana. "I'm actually basing my testimony not on speculation, but on concerns that have already been made, and on issues that came up during the soft roll-out."

The ACLU's deputy director for Pa, Barb Feige, sent us a letter yesterday on our story on prominent Pittsburghers on the no-ID rolls and the interactive feature allowing Allegheny County residents to see if they're on the no-ID list. Even if that feature tells voters they're in the clear, they may not be. She writes:

To be absolutely certain that one has acceptable ID, voters should do the following:

  •       Check the list of IDs that will be accepted and make sure you have one
  • Make sure that the ID has an expiration date ( PennDOT IDs can be expired up to one year.)
  • Make sure that the name on your ID closely matches the name on your registration (a problem for many women who changed their names when they got married)
  •      Make sure that the photo on that ID matches your current appearance (mainly a concern for transgender voters).

And Chris Potter at Pittsburgh City Paper continues to do his great work on the issue. Check out the diagram below for more discussion on the state's stipulation on fraud evidence (click to go directly to CP site, and go to the last page):

cpvoterid

Print

NYT: Pa not top tier battleground, leans Obama

Published by Tim McNulty on .

Following up on this morning's Q poll results, the NYT is moving its rating on the presidential race in Pa to the Democratic column. Reporter Jeff Zeleny explains:

Pennsylvania, whose 20 electoral votes have long been among the most closely watched in the race for the White House, is now rated as Leaning Democratic, according to the latest New York Times ranking of presidential battlegrounds.

The state had previously been ranked as a Tossup. But so far, neither President Obama nor Mitt Romney has invested considerable money on television advertising in the state and a new Quinnipiac University/New York Times/CBS News poll of likely voters in Pennsylvania found that Mr. Obama has an advantage of 11 percentage points.

The poll, with a margin of error of plus or minus three percentage points, affirms what both campaigns have already discovered: Pennsylvania – for now, at least – is not among the top tier of battlegrounds.

The state has voted for a Democratic presidential candidate in the last five elections. Mr. Romney is still waging an aggressive fight, but the terrain is likely more difficult than in the eight other remaining Tossup states in the Times' rankings: Colorado, Florida, Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada, Ohio, Virginia and Wisconsin.

Print

Dermody questions Voter ID letters

Published by Tim McNulty on .

Even voters who are aware of the state's new Voter ID rules get confused when the state tries to explain them.

Just ask House Minority Leader Frank Dermody.

Apparently because the Oakmont Democrat is registered as "Francis" he was one of Allegheny County's nearly 100,000 voters (and 758K statewide) alerted by letter recently that his information doesn't match up exactly with PennDOT license records. Except the form letter from the state doesn't exactly say that, and Dermody (a vocal critic of the new GOP-approved requirements) wasn't sure what to make of it. From a statement he issued yesterday:

"The problem is this letter does not do what the state claims it does. There is no explicit warning that the recipient of the letter may lack the proper ID. People who have voted for years without problems know little about the new law and will assume they are fine," Dermody said.

"Nothing in this letter will make them think otherwise or get them to check their ID. My guess is many people threw away the letter without giving it another thought.

"If this letter was truly the first step in a statewide educational campaign, then I have to question the planning that went into it and the overall effectiveness at reaching voters, not to mention the hundreds of thousands of dollars it cost to mail this letter," Dermody said.

Others in Dermody's predicament interviewed by the P-G yesterday shared his confusion with the letters. Read for yourself (click for larger version):

dermodyltrsmall

Print

Kelly: Contraception like 9/11, Pearl Harbor

Published by Tim McNulty on .

Never one to shun the spotlight, US Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, is back in the headlines today.

From NBC:

A House Republican lawmaker likened the implementation of a new mandate that insurers offer coverage for contraceptive services to Pearl Harbor and the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks against the United States.

Pennsylvania Rep. Mike Kelly (R), an ardent opponent of abortion rights, said that today's date would live in infamy alongside those two other historic occasions. Wednesday marked the day on which a controversial new requirement by the Department of Health and Human Services, which requires health insurance companies to cover contraceptive services for women, goes into effect.

"I know in your mind you can think of times when America was attacked. One is December 7th, that's Pearl Harbor day.  The other is September 11th, and that's the day of the terrorist attack," Kelly said at a press conference on Capitol Hill. "I want you to remember August the 1st, 2012, the attack on our religious freedom. That is a day that will live in infamy, along with those other dates."

UPDATE: Kelly's Democratic challenger Missa Eaton says Kelly owes 9/11 and Pearl Harbor survivors an apology. Her statement:

"First and foremost, Mike Kelly must absolutely apologize to the victims and families affected by the horrible attacks on Pearl Harbor and on 9/11. The comparison is ludicrous and compares foreign acts of aggression upon our nation to a piece of domestic legislation that sincerely tries to provide women with access to quality, affordable healthcare."

UPDATE 2. Kelly's official statement is after the jump:

Print

Obama back to eastern Ohio

Published by Tim McNulty on .

Barack Obama is back across the border in northeastern Ohio today, less than a month since his post-Independence Day bus tour of Ohio and Pittsburgh, which ended at CMU.

Jackie Calmes at the NYT notes he's flying into a controversy around Mansfield and Akron that should sound familiar to Pittsburghers worried about the 911th in Moon:

But Mr. Obama was flying, literally, into a controversy in Mansfield that Republicans, led by Senator Rob Portman of Ohio, a potential running mate for Mr. Romney, were only too happy to fan. According to local media, Air Force One was landing at an air base that is home to the 179th Air National Guard Wing, which would be mothballed under the Obama administration’s proposed postwar reductions in Pentagon spending.